UPA Perpustakaan Universitas Jember

The Trial of Joseph Dotterweich: The Origins of the ‘‘Responsible Corporate Officer’’ Doctrine

LERNE, Craig S. - Personal Name

This article analyzes the origins of the ‘‘responsible corporate officer’’ doctrine:
the trial of Joseph Dotterweich. That doctrine holds that an officer may be personally liable
for the criminal act of a subordinate if the officer was, in some indefinite way, able to
prevent the violation. Applying this doctrine, the prosecution of Dotterweich entailed strict
liability for a strict liability offense. The underlying offenses—the interstate sale of one
misbranded and adulterated drug and one misbranded drug—were said to be strict liability
offenses. And then, with respect to Dotterweich as the corporation’s general manager, the
government argued that he was strictly liable because he stood in ‘‘responsible relation’’ to
the company’s acts. The government never tried to prove that the company, Buffalo
Pharmacal, was negligent, nor did it try to prove that Dotterweich was negligent in his
supervision of the employees of Buffalo Pharmacal. The prosecutor and judge were candid
about this theory throughout the trial, although the judge conceded that it seemed bizarre
and unfair. The defense lawyer repeatedly sought to inject what became known throughout
the trial as the ‘‘question of good faith,’’ but was circumvented at almost every turn. What
would thus seem to be the crux of any criminal trial—the personal fault of the defendant—
was carefully shorn from the jury’s consideration. The government’s theory was so at odds
with intuitive notions of liability and blame that, as one probes into the case, and looks at
the language used in the government’s appellate briefs, imputations of moral fault inevitably
crept in. Yet the government was not entitled to make such accusations, as it had
pruned moral considerations from the trial. The article argues that the responsible corporate
officer doctrine can never enjoy a secure place in our legal system. First, the
doctrine is at a minimum in tension with, and often in direct opposition to, basic principles
of the criminal law; and second, the doctrine fails, when followed to its logical conclusions,
to accord with basic notions of fair play. The article concludes that the responsible
corporate officer doctrine is either unnecessary, in cases in which the evidence establishes
personal fault, or unjust, in cases in which it creates liability in the absence of personal
& Craig S. Lerner
clerner@gmu.edu
1 Antonin Scalia Law School, George Mason University, Fairfax, VA, USA
123
Crim Law and Philos
DOI 10.1007/s11572-017-9439-4
fault through the unspecified notion of ‘‘responsibility.’’ The Dotterweich case illustrates
what is contemplated by the latter possibility, and why it is problematic in any judicial
system that purports, in the words of the Model Penal Code, ‘‘to safeguard conduct that is
without fault from condemnation as criminal.’’

EB00000004359K Available

Detail Information

Series Title

Call Number

Publisher

: ,

Collation

Language

ISBN/ISSN

Classification

NONE

Detail Information

Content Type

E-Jurnal

Media Type

Carrier Type

Edition

Subject(s)

Mens rea
Strict liability
Responsible corporate officer
Dotterweich
White-collar crim

Specific Detail Info

Statement of Responsibility

Craig S. Lerne

No other version available

The Trial of Joseph Dotterweich: The Origins of the ‘‘Responsible Corporate Officer’’ Doctrine

UPA Perpustakaan

Merupakan Unit Pendukung Akademis (UPA) yang bersama-sama dengan unit lain melaksanakan Tri Dharma Perguruan Tinggi (PT) melalui menghimpun, memilih, mengolah, merawat serta melayankan sumber informasi kepada civitas akademika Universitas Jember khususnya dan masyarakat akademis pada umumnya.

VISI

UPA Perpustakaan Universitas Jember sebagai perpustakaan modern dengan layanan prima yang mampu menunjang visi Universitas Jember.

MISI

Menyelenggarakan pembinaan dan pengembangan ketersediaan bahan pustaka dan informasi ilmiah sesuai dengan kebutuhan pemustaka secara berkelanjutan

Meningkatkan kualitas dan sistem manajemen layanan perpustakaan secara professional dengan memanfaatkan teknologi informasi

Membina dan mengembangkan jaringan kerjasama dengan pusat-pusat informasi dan lembaga terkait dalam dan luar negeri

UPA Perpustakaan Universitas Jember

NPP. 3509212D1000001

The Trial of Joseph Dotterweich: The Origins of the ‘‘Responsible Corporate Officer’’ Doctrine

LERNE, Craig S. - Personal Name

Series Title

Call Number

Publisher

Collation

Language

ISBN/ISSN

Classification

Content Type

Media Type

Carrier Type

Edition

Subject(s)

Specific Detail Info

Statement of Responsibility

About Us

UPA Perpustakaan

Total Koleksi

Total Item

Total Member

Total Pustakawan

Total Terpinjam

Peminjaman Tahun 2025

Peminjaman 5 Tahun

Peminjaman Bulan June 2025

Total Pengunjung

Pengunjung Tahun 2025

Pengunjung 5 Tahun Terakhir

Pengunjung Bulan June 2025

New collection + Update

Analisis Kekuatan Tarik Dan Bending Serat Pelepah Pinang Sebagai Penguat Material Komposit

Prarancangan Pabrik Furfural Dari Tempurung Kelapa Melalui Proses Zeitsch Dengan Kapasitas 12.000 Ton/tahun

faktor yang mempengaruhi produktifitas pekerja wanita bagian cetak pada pabrik kerupuk andalas kecamtan kali puro kabupaten banyuwangi tahun 2010

prosedur administrasi pembayaran santunan klaim meninggal dunia pada asuransi bersama (AJB) bumi putera 1912 cabang jember

Akuntansi Aktiva = Utang + Modal

pelaksanaan administrasi pembayaran klaim untuk pserta wajib pada pt(persero) aske indoneia cabang jember

Aplikasi Android

Our Services

Help Desk and Service Support UPA Perpustakaan

Tautan Pintas :

Jam Layanan :

Senin - Kamis:

Jum'at:

Sabtu dan Minggu:

Alamat & Kontak Info :

Jalan Kalimantan No. 37 - Kampus Bumi Tegalboto Kotak POS 159 Jember, Jawa Timur, 68121, Indonesia

library@unej.ac.id

(+62) 331 333860