RECORD DETAIL


Back To Previous

UPA Perpustakaan Universitas Jember

Reconsidering Illegal Hunting as a Crime of Dissent Implication for Justice and Deliberative Uptake

No image available for this title
In this paper, we determine whether illegal hunting should be construed as a crime of dissent. Using the Nordic countries as a case study where protest-driven, illegal hunting of protected wolves is on the rise, we reconsider the crime using principles of
civil disobedience. We invoke the conditions of intentionality, nonevasion, dialogic effort, non-violence and appeal to parameters of reasonable disagreement about justice and situate the Nordic illegal hunting phenomenon at a nexus between conscientious objection, assisted disobedience and everyday resistance. This examination leads us to contend that the crime has heretofore received an inadequate response limited to punishmentand deterrence. This contentio n finds support in the worsening predicaments of illegal hunting following harsh sanctions and stigmatization. Although hunters publicize
injustices through their crimes, we find that killing wolves as a means to deliberative ends disqualifies hunters’ dissent as legitimate disobedience, creating an obligation of deliberative uptake on the part of society. Nonetheless, in a critical contribution to the field of criminal justice, we argue that it is instead the conditions of deliberative suboptimality
experienced by hunters that create this obligation of uptake. Hence, in order to fulfill this obligation, we contend that the burden falls on regulatory agencies to better articulate the justifications for the policies that coerce hunters. We also advocate creating novel institutions to provide hunters with effective opportunities for contesting wildlife conservation
directives.

Availability
EB00000004156KAvailable
Detail Information

Series Title

-

Call Number

-

Publisher

: ,

Collation

-

Language

ISBN/ISSN

-

Classification

NONE

Detail Information

Content Type

E-Jurnal

Media Type

-

Carrier Type

-

Edition

-

Specific Detail Info

-

Statement of Responsibility

No other version available
File Attachment